How best to govern a diverse population is a part of the subtext of public political debates in America, mostly because no one is permitted to debate the orthodoxy on immigration, so America gets more diverse every day. This is treated as a novelty that only the best minds in the managerial elite can tackle. In reality, humans have been dealing with diversity since the first human settlements. It turns out that there are only five solutions to the problem posed by diversity.
The most common way of dealing with the problem of diversity is also the oldest way of dealing with diversity. That is for the dominant tribe to subjugate or even eradicate the alien tribes from their land. The people of one place finally get the upper hand over the people adjacent to them and wipe them out. Alternatively, the main identity group in the newly formed society compels the minorities to adopt their identity. Wiping out diversity is the oldest cure for diversity.
The trouble is it rarely works, especially when you are dealing with large numbers of people in tight communities. The Israelis are trying to drive off the Arabs in Gaza, even going so far as to deliberately massacre civilians, but they are no closer to pushing out the Arabs than when they started their genocidal campaign against them. Even with modern tools, it is extremely hard to remove a large population. It is possible, but in this age, even the Israelis cannot get away with it.
That leaves the four more civilized options. One is to simply keep the various identity groups apart to reduce friction. This was common in the northern cities of the United States into the 20th century. The old neighborhood system that is romanticized today used to be rigorously policed by the authorities to make sure blacks were not going into Italian areas and vice-versa. Keeping the peace meant keeping the groups as separate as possible from one another.
In the South there was a soft version of segregation. Diversity primarily meant blacks, who were systematically segregated from whites in largely symbolic ways. Blacks and whites could share public spaces, but had to maintain separation, even if it were mostly symbolic like riding in the back of the bus. This performative segregation was to reinforce the notion that the two races could never mix. Segregation became a habit of mind, rather than physical separation.
Both of those effective and popular systems were overthrown by the managerial elite in favor of the chaos of the present. This system does not have a catchy name, like segregation or Jim Crow, but proportionalism will do. The system of rights that had been the basis of America society was abandoned in favor of egalitarian ideals to which the elites make exceptions in order to achieve what they arbitrarily see as a proportional outcome among the various tribes of America.
The growing tyranny that must come from such a system is what is driving the academic debates about the civil rights revolution and the rear guard action to hold the line against DIE programs in the institutions. Of course, the people responsible for this disaster are not interested in altering course. They are especially uninterested in the fourth option which is to not manage the diversity at all. This was the way America managed diversity through most of the 19th century.
A good example of this is in this interesting post about an old house by one of the professors in that linked video. He bought an old farmhouse and got curious about its history, so he did the research. It turns out that his house has a diverse history that reflects the way diversity was managed in early America. Basically, people were left to sort themselves out as best they could, which generally meant peaceful separation when peaceful cohabitation was not possible.
As pointed out in that post, who people are, in terms of their primary identity, is how they live, and no amount of downward force can change it. This is why the path of proportionalism as practiced by our tyrants must lead to that first and oldest option for dealing with diversity. They are trying to wipe out whiteness, by which they mean white people, through a campaign of cultural genocide, along with the importation of nonwhites in numbers no society can sustain.
The trouble is that wiping out even a small minority is difficult. Purging America of “whiteness” when most of the population is white and determined to live as they prefer, in the teeth of the cultural pogroms, is impossible. This brings us to the irreconcilable contradiction that lies at the heart of the current crisis. For the ruling elite to remain the currently constructed ruling elite they must continue with proportionalism, even though it must fail and lead to their eventual overthrow.
What all of this points to is both a solution to the current tyrannical regime and the challenge of diversity. Because whites will remain the largest population and will increase their self-segregation in response to their shrinking majority and the cultural assault on them from the elites, the racial tyranny must collapse. Put another way, the old solution of self-sorting, the habit of frontier America, will be the rocks upon which the racial tyrants will be destroyed.
This may seem overly optimistic, but the reality is the current regime is fighting human nature, which is undefeated in fights of this sort. Ideology, and the racialized politics of this age are ideological, is hostile to human nature. Communism did not fail due to technical errors. It failed because it was inhuman. The same is true of the racial ideology of the managerial class. Peaceful separation is the natural state of Americans, and it will be it natural order again.
If you like my work and wish to donate, you can buy me a beer. You can sign up for a SubscribeStar or a Substack subscription and get some extra content. You can donate via PayPal. My crypto addresses are here for those who prefer that option. You can send gold bars through the postal service to: Z Media LLC P.O. Box 1047 Berkeley Springs, WV 25411-3047. Thank you for your support!
Promotions: Good Svffer is an online retailer partnering with several prolific content creators on the Dissident Right, both designing and producing a variety of merchandise including shirts, posters, and books. If you are looking for a way to let the world know you are one of us without letting the world know you are one one is us, then you should but a shirt with the Lagos Trading Company logo.
Havamal Soap Works is the maker of natural, handmade soap and bath products. If you are looking to reduce the volume of man-made chemicals in your life, all-natural personal products are a good start.
Minter & Richter Designs makes high-quality, hand-made by one guy in Boston, titanium wedding rings for men and women and they are now offering readers a fifteen percent discount on purchases if you use this link. If you are headed to Boston, they are also offering my readers 20% off their 5-star rated Airbnb. Just email them directly to book at sales@minterandrichterdesigns.com.
Let’s hope so. But I do not see this happening in the next decade or two.
Additionally, I am not sure blacks want separation. As you have said, blacks define themselves in opposition to white people. They need to live near or among whites.
Well said. Without access to whites the true ability of blacks to only destroy will come to the forefront.
Moreover, almost the entirety of their middle class is wholly dependent upon racial wealth transfers taken from whites. Of course, this will put more strain on the proportionalist system. De facto reparations are being paid now. First LaGuardia and now JFK will be enhanced/expanded and no white men are eligible for contracts – not a penny. Boston is going to pay reparations. A town in PA just pulled a NY JFK with several billion. It won’t be long before non-blacks wonder why they are paying reparations and then begin to demand the lion’s share of the spoils. The same is… Read more »
Somewhere in that crowd are men who have had enough and make plans to go up to the cockpit and sort things out.
It will have to get a lot worse before that happens because damn this seat is comfortable, the beer is still cold and being served, and they have a window seat and it’s a beautiful day…
“The American Negro” by E. Frazier was published in the late 1940’s. It’s really interesting to read his quite open account of black promiscuity, illegitimacy and crime from slavery through the 40’s.
The conclusion he draws, though, is that blacks will have better outcomes once white people overcome prejudice.
One reads these early writings from folks out of intellectual curiosity and some historical observations pre-woke society, but one should ignore all such theories of cause and effect and solution they present to their reader. They’ve all been tried and *HBD science* has come into its own with superior theories of cause and effect. Solutions to correct human biology is not yet quite there, but the understanding of where the problem lies is the most solid understanding we’ve had to date.
Personally, I don’t give a shit about negro outcomes.
Sure, that’s fine. My reference is to the fairly standard trope of “bigotry and prejudice” for all the ill’s of Blacks in the USA. I give those “ancients” a pass, because they knew no better. Today, to say such things is *willfully* ignorant—not “well meaning”.
They define themselves by the baubles built and created by the Blue-eyed Ice Devil: sail foams, Escalades, basketball, electrified music, watches, etc. They have no interest in returning to mud huts and carrion. But in time, they will have no choice in the matter.
Peaceful separation would be ideal, but I wouldn’t count on it. Our managerial “elites” are hell bent on shoving their proportionality ideology down our throats and seemingly nothing other than probable bloodshed is likely to dissuade them.
The bloodshed is inevitable, hell it’s already happening. Do you see any signs of reality being accepted? Come hell or high water they’ll cram that square peg in there…
The sorting is the acceptance of reality. Disregard the platitudes about “content of their character” as someone seeks out “better schools.” People know and are responding.
If bloodshed ensues cause of famine or something, that’s a good thing.
The groups with the most rural people win, that’s always been the case.
This means whites and mexicans come out on top.
Minnesotan somalis and indians, they’re fucked.
So are the african americans.
The only question is China.
Chinese will be able to take over if they wish to do so.
“Peaceful separation would be ideal, but I wouldn’t count on it.” In exactly three decades, the locale I live in changed due to fedgov policies. Aided and abetted by locals, slum lords, corrupt law enforcement and their ilk. We buy a house in a bucolic setting, albeit one hour from a major city. Still, country, local Main Street, all the trappings. Quiet. First come the illegals. A horde of them to such an extent that Main Street now features Spanish as the first language and we avoid ‘going through’ what is now a barrio. Then came the Section 8 housing,… Read more »
They are parasites and when does a parasite ever care about killing the host…
Exactly, it just finds another host.
This sounds an awful like the Village of Brewster, NY.
I gather Brewster is feeling a bit punky…
Don’t you worry. Radical, VAST changes are coming soon, and the diversity problem will be whisked away, almost as if it never happened. We who survive it all will have *much* more basic concerns to deal with every day.
Yes, that’s an excellent observation. From one viewpoint, in the old days (e.g. before the massive legislative juggernaut that was Civil Rights) individual groups had far more freedom of association, which is simply another name for peaceful separation. To be sure, it was often accomplished by legal means like the Jim Crow laws. Yet much of it, perhaps most, was simply private groups asserting the freedom of exclusion in their private affairs. (Legal discriminations like racial covenants in deeds or other legal contracts are a middle ground between those two extremes, in my view.) If a private club, the owner… Read more »
I know I’ve mentioned this before, but I started in Rotary right around the time women began making inroads into the corporate world. Of course, Rotary (along with most of the other significant service clubs) were male only. Well, that just couldn’t be cause the gals wouldn’t have access to the “old boys network”. So the yammering began and the organization folded up like wet paper bag. It’s going to take a lot of testicular fortitude to roll all that crap (and more) back.
The Elks Club says, “hello!”
Personally, I’ve always been parshul to the Racoon Lodge…
Except for Joe Fensterblau.
The separation part is inevitable. It isn’t peaceful now.
There will be separation. The questions are when, how, how much area and where, violent or peaceful, etc. So much is unknown, but nature and reality says living together in multi-racial, chaotic, tense, low-trust, society will not and cannot continue.
I wish I could believe that. It hasn’t been working for decades yet nothing much changes. Things just get worse and worse, but the band plays on.
But the power structure is steadily weakening. There will come a time when it won’t be able to shove anything upon anybody. It is then that that racial separatism with formalize.
My first instinct is that the article is overly optimistic. However as bad as it is we are blessed with ridiculously stupid and violent proxy enemies. Everyone can certainly see that now.
An immigration attorney I once worked with quite a bit one said regarding the merits of immigration: “George if it comes to to all of them or none of them, I prefer none of them”.
One group I can think of would starve if they were separated to live alone.
They would have to grow food themselves, and that would be like slavery or sumting!
Kinda like a group claiming they were holocausted because they were made to work…
Worked to extinction!
Oddly, during the years they were being extincted, some 6 million of them appeared in the US, UK, Canada, USSR, and Plucky.
“Yes, people with vastly different cultures and belief systems can get along. It does happen. But the opposite is much more common. As Dutch Foreign Minister Stef Blok observed in a talk to representatives of international organizations: ‘I have asked my ministry this and I will pose the question here as well. Give me an example of a multi-ethnic or multi-cultural society in which the original population still lives, and where there is a peaceful cohabitation. I don’t know of one.’ If you’ve got social division, then deal with it as well as you can. Avoid doing anything that would… Read more »
You could kind of point to Singapore as the exception, and maybe Malaysia as well, although the native Malays have hiring preference written into the nation’s constitution.
I visited Singapore several times during my imperial service. Singapore is majority ethnic Chinese. It was MUCH nicer than the state in which I grew up (b/c no blacks, of course). It’s been a while since I paid attention to it, but the governing authorities did not have a passive ‘live and let live’ attitude. They kept a FIRM proactive grip on ethnic tension. If the ruling Singaporean Chinese have abandoned that attitude and allowed themselves to become a minority in their own country, I expect you will find GAE fingerprints on the transformation project.
Singapore would seem to be a “benign” dictatorship of sorts. The competing three minorities assigned their “place” in that society—but I’m no expert here, except to note I’ve heard of grumbling there too.
As far as hiring quotas go, SA seems to have done this to their detriment. Reality dictates the need for meritocracy, not equality.
Note that the Asians, being race realists- that is, not having a Bible- do tend to keep a very firm and realistic grip on ethnic differences and hierarchy, even as those sub-ethnicities are readily acknowledged.
As examples, many dialects in China whether under Mongol or Han rule; the Khia, Viet, Montagnards in Vietnam; Khmer Rouge, Jeune, and Verde in Cambodia; Hmong in Laos. And of course, Malay in Malaysia.
Good article,
Although my observation at this point in time is that the suburban peasant has not yet arrived at seperation being a viable option.
He needs to see more white people replaced and denigrated in his media watching, a few more George Floyd burn downs of his cities,and more section 8 housing and catalytic converter thieves in his neighborhood.
But we are on our way.
Civ Nats need to feel the burn before they wake up. Especially the soccer mons. They will not leave go of their color blind utopia no matter how much white blood is spilled, no matter how many of their daughters are gang raped, pimped out sex slaves, or how many are killed.
They need to feel the sting on a personal, intimate level. I have zero sympathy for them.
They need to feel the sting on a personal, intimate level I think that pretty much applies to anyone not just normies…I know quite a few people in the dissident sphere that still live around blacks because they haven’t had an incident with them…
The clearest window to the future is the present.
The normal human reaction to witnessing violence, humiliation, etc., done to his people is to submit to it—as the statistically average American man is doing.
The “warrior”/woman reaction is to join in it—as cops and HR ladies are doing.
Resistance is rare and strange. Only rare and strange men consider it.
From Zman’s lips to God’s ear. The rising tide of immigrant mediocrity, coupled with the genocidal sense of entitlement unleased by the egalitarian lotus eaters, has stripped American white men of the fruits of their civilization-building efforts. If we are to enjoy peace once again, majority rule and universal suffrage must end. Apartheid now, each neighborhood and then town or city in turn. Redlining, sundowner laws, preferential hiring and business deals, social shunning and free association. All the old tools need to be employed, but latently rather than by explicit measures. Every effort by the Feds, the NGOs and the… Read more »
If have a friend that grew up in St. Louis. He went to the community college in Forrest Park. He is of Austrian descent, he was friends with all the Italians, went to church with all the Italians, and worked with the Italians. He couldn’t get an apartment on “The Hill” because he wasn’t Italian. I don’t know how it is today, but “The Hill” was a nice safe place in a sea $hit. As an aside, I was designing a large infrastructure project for a White suburban town and had to hold public meetings (stupid government contract). Public meetings… Read more »
I live within a small school district in a wealthy neighborhood. I use such arguments regularly. It is a very simple problem of running the number of how a couple hundred section 8 housing units would produce 400+ student in a district of 2000 or so students. From there some percentages can be produced. There are studies to show a decline in school efficiency/function/quality/safety when the minority enrollment tops 5%. 20% is a death knell.
‘Students’ = thugs needing a holding pen (‘school’).
I grew up close to the Hill and was in high school when the desegregation orders came down from a Missouri judge in the late 1970s. The black northside schools and white southside schools were forced to mix through a bussing program. Of course, chaos ensued, and white families moved out of the city and into surrounding counties in large numbers. The city population has dropped from 470K prior to desegregation to 277K today. The racial makeup went from about 50/50 to 12% white today. This backs Zman’s point, and shows that segregation will always re-emerge once the liberal do-gooders… Read more »
If I know of someone passing through East St Louis on I -55, or 64, I tell them never to get off the interstate – no matter what. Assume that is still good advice?
Yes, and that will still be good advice 100 years from now.
Along these lines Anglin once wrote that ‘affordable housing’ means nogger sh!thole. Section 8 is the death knell of any pre-existing community.
Even landlords eventually pull out of section 8 after a few (bad) experiences. However, they are replaced due to loan incentives and low income housing requirement to get permits. sigh.
We are the authors of our own misery. Why are there so many blacks in Africa? Because whites feed them and they breed like flies. Whites set up hospitals and clinics for people that believe in spirits, curses and witch doctors. So more is fed to them, and the result is more blacks that need to be fed. An old stubfart blogger named Kim du Toit became a radioactive pariah and heretic when he penned a screed entitled “Let Africa Sink”. And 20 years later – here is our own esteemed blogger repeating the heresy! 😂👍 But…they’re both right. If… Read more »
Sailer had his Most Important Graph up for years, that Africa population hockey stick.
NGOs look at that and salivate over the liberal-mandated grifting opportunities being handed to them.
The above example echoes the baleful free market, open borders, wishful thinking of the Insulated Useful Idiots found on college campuses, often with tenure. The canny ones wangle grant writers to keep the dough rising, for research.
The most important graph is *only* important because in presumes the fleeing hoards of Africa will meet little resistance from the Western nations. This is a valid fear and a good guess. However, a closure of the borders to such is not an impossibility even for a shrinking West, and the African hoards will never be able through force of arms breach a determined West. There just isn’t the IQ power. The problem of a growing Africa will solve itself in a couple generations—tops—if Western aid stops and refugees to the West are halted. Harsh I admit, but the alternative… Read more »
The problem with Sailer’s graph, and in general, is that no nation in Africa can feed itself, so all this growth is dependent on food imports from the first world…mainly Russia, the US, Canada, and some countries in South America…Those exports will not continue indefinitely, as the West continues to destroy farm land and impose restrictions on it because of the Global Warming fraud….So the whole system is going to collapse at some point…
I too subscribe to this dismal theory; I’m not sure if it has an official name but civilizational collapse will do for now. It may be worth noting that Whites too will take huge damage in the big crash, if and when it comes. The present world is unsustainable, and that would likely remain the case even if population grows slowed to zero, which I’m pretty sure it hasn’t. As noted, the poorest places breed prolifically and the only reason they aren’t already visited more than they are by war, famine and pestilence is due to aid from the rich world.… Read more »
“..opportunity to rape the poor nations for whatever natural resources and other wealth that can be stripped from them.”
That’s a tired old trope. It takes two as they say. There is no “rape” without connivance of corrupt elites—certainly since the end of colonialism. Additionally I would challenge anyone to point to a “poor” country that has been raped to the point that their “natural resources” have been extinguished. Rather what we see mainly today are bunches of 3rd world countries with great resources that are squandered through ignorance and greed—but not our ignorance and greed, theirs.
Kim du Toit
du Toit was also an anti-apartheid activist in his younger days and refuses to disavow that. He left his fellow South Africans behind to suffer the effects of what he pushed for. He’d seem all red-pilled about Africa, but he’d never take the side of Whites in their own country.
True. I don’t consider him a dissident in the way we understand the term. He’s always been an old Boomer that can sometimes peer into the workings of the Matrix, but will never see the big picture. If you were to point all that out to him, V… the response would almost certainly be cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy. Nevertheless, he is one of the first to challenge the black/Africa narratives of the time by speaking the truth about it. Not defending him…but for me…I think of some of the things that I used to believe and just want to die… Read more »
I remember that guy! I was not aware of the essay that torpedoed him though, so thank you, now I have something else to read today.
Q: What do you get when you feed 500 starving Africans?
A: 5,000 starving Africans.
Being from the northeast, a former steel city, I was surprised how integrated blacks were driving through the south for the first time to Florida in the late 90’s. I was always lead to believe (falsly as it turns out) in the north blacks were more free to integrate, and of course the southern rebels would keep things segregated as best they could, even under the feds forced integration. Well its the exact opposite. The southerners have been living side by side with large swaths of blacks for centuries. They are acclimated to it. In the north east, blacks and… Read more »
Rural WNY/Southern Tier is a beautiful place that, God willing, will be freed from this madness in our lifetimes. It’s still salvageable.
Amen brother!
People who couldn’t get along with their European homelands, or those seeking adventure, came to America. People who couldn’t work in early colonial society, or those with dreams of land, went West. Those who wanted to avoid ethnic rivalries congregated to their own ethnic conclaves in the city. When ethnic conclaves in the city were destroyed, they retreated to the suburbs. Now the suburbs are under attack, every small town is introduced to diversity with Section 8, and the government is confiscating all the frontier land they can. Whites have always run to just be left alone, and now there’s… Read more »
This is a theme in Tom Wolfe’s four novels, shown in the title of his last, “Back to Blood.” Where I live in California, the whites are being driven out to other states (except for the very rich), while the others form their own communities: East LA and Santa Ana are Mexican, Glendale is Armenian, Diamond Bar is Korean and Chinese, etc. The homeless are everywhere and growing in numbers. Our governor could be your next president.
That’d be bad enough, but even more to be feared might be a former Attorney General and Senatress from your State.
I think Willie Brown’s former adulterous would actually be better than The Hair. You’re getting the same anti-white policies either way, but at least you wouldn’t have the slick veneer to charm suburban white women. And she put the lie to the saying that once you go black you don’t go back, more accurately translated as once you go back we don’t want you back. But she went so far back she married a Jew.
Z’s essay today strikes an optimistic tone, to me at the least. Nevertheless, perhaps a bit too optimistic.
The separation of Whites fleeing diverse areas has mostly been conducted in a way to avoid being thought of as a racist. Typically it’s “we’re moving to a better school district.” Recently a friend in Minnesota told me about a proposed new housing development in a mostly white, outer suburb of the Twin Cities, Lino Lakes. It’s called the Madinah Lakes Project, and features a big mosque at the center of it. If approved, Lino Lakes would have a large number of Somalians moving out to their nice white suburb. There is a lot of opposition to the new development,… Read more »
‘Better school district’ is code for less minorities.
And even more accurately, fewer negroes. The Hutu is the nec plus ultra of dieversity.
In the Twin Cities, diversity mandates for new construction are enforced by the Metropolitan Council, which was formed in the ’60s/’70s to facilitate the construction of the freeway system. The original idea was to form a multi-county governance structure that could override local zoning laws which might interfere with the construction of the freeway system. It was successful for a few decades, but as per O’Sullivan’s law it eventually was taken over by the political left. One of the powers granted the Met Council was management of the water systems for the metropolitan counties. Now, any developer in these metropolitan… Read more »
*Shrug* — you say ‘managerial elite’ whereas I say ‘the Tribe.’ The Tribe controls the key institutions and so sets both the domestic and foreign agenda. Both to the detriment of white people. Imperial collapse internationally and domestically will bring about some kind of reset. But I’m clueless about what the contours will be.
The great thing about the Israeli / hamas debacle and the shrieking pussy hats on college campus’s is the tribes grip on being the moral high priests as Z man would say, is beginning to slip. Hopefully its just the first domino to fall.
Sad thing is it should have been white men calling jewish power straight up, not shrieking blue haired, batshit crazy women.
But alas, white men have handed everyone the keys to the kingdom.
Yep. A lot of the cucks going on about anti-Semitism really are criticizing anti-white racism but don’t have the balls to do so explicitly, at least yet. The Hamas fanbois, on the other hand, are attacking Jews only because they see them as white. The dominoes are falling indeed.
It will be interesting to see how the Jewish strategy of importing new tribes, so they can band together against a future Hitler of the white tribe, will play out when the new tribes actually see them as the worst subset of the white tribe.
I see the managerial elite system as simply a tool of the Tribe. The managerial elite is mostly just human cattle stampeded in whatever direction the Tribes media/edumacation system points them. I learned at Unz about another book that was part of the erased resistance of our forefathers to Jewish rape of America: “The Iron Curtain over America by John Beaty (1951).” That was also where I learned about Henry Ford’s “The International Jew” (1931). Yes, it’s not all of them (Unz is Jewish, and doing Godly work), but it is consistently some of them wherever they go. Faction balancing… Read more »
Yes, that makes sense. The Tribe has set up a structure where worthy white cucks can be promoted to NCO rank. But always contingent on continued good behavior. Macron and Schulz are NCOs.
All respect to our host, but I’m starting to think Unz’s American Pravda series is the best thing on the internet. Shame that most clown world attention spans aren’t up to reading anything that long.
I agree. I print them out so that I can grok them in fullness. They often run to 30 or 40 pages.
Absolutely. Magnificent.
For instance, I learned last night that “Ukrainian” Nikita Khrushchev’s real name was Solomon Pearl Mutter, married to a Ukrainian Banderite wife.
Also, that the former name of “the Borderlands” or “the Plain” was New Serbia and Slaveno-Serbia until 1750.
The good news is, the Unzes are the heirs to a previous vanguard such as Gottfried and Irving. May they prove to be the new elite to overthrow the old, amongst their own as we must ours. These acorns, we must shelter and succor.
I’m assuming this is a joke. Khrushchev was no Finkel.
This is about the most peaceful solution. Which is why I’m not hopeful for it.
This was really good. I have to applaud Z-Man for giving a succinct and accurate overview of the racial political problem in America that does not once mention the B-word. This proves that the Dissident Right can grow up and move beyond HBD, which is essential for it to get off the fringe and into the mainstream discussion. This is exactly what’s needed, and a lot more of it. I endorse every word. Coffee bought.
Spoken as always without one example of where an understanding of HBD negatively affects the movement in any way. Again, the challenge is made: How is a scientific basis of Human Diversity a detriment to the DR?
I certainly can think of the counter example. If HBD does not exist, then everyone is equal. If everyone is equal, then separation of the people into enclaves of “likeness” is unjustifiable outside of human prejudice. Which means basically, not much reason for the DR to exist or most of the discussion in the commentary.
Not only does separation become unjustifiable, but enforced equality must also then be justified. Because what other explanation than racism could there be for disparity of results?
The sorting underway proves your point. Throwing open the border has accelerated the process, and attempts to confine the vibrancy to areas without what is perceived as enough of it are all but impossible. “You stay where the bus dropped you off!” the diverse migrant is berated. “You stay where we dropped off the diverse migrant!” the white man is warned. Of course, diversity flows toward the urban setting with the most gibs, and whites congregate into increasingly segregated and removed redoubts. Everything old is new again. To bang my old hobby horse, the white Puritan who drives most of… Read more »
Has anyone noticed how Cloward – Piven explains what has been happening?
Lots of blood and treasure will be spilled before that happens though, so better be prepared for that…
Not possible in a world where blacks have the legal right to murder Whites. D.C, Lagos, and Birmingham did not become black Hellscapes through cunning, but through state-sanctioned violence. Whites were driven out of their historical neighborhoods through violence and those neighborhoods became exclusively black. Peaceful separation is, in fact, wildly optimistic.
However the political and territorial separation takes place, I’ve always felt it will be necessary for the coastal leftist shitholes to continue their existence. The only reasonable way to get the brown horde out of our hair will be to cut off all gibs to non-whites immediately and completely. Having leftist enclaves as neighbors will provide Yadier, Pablo, and even Barkevious with an obvious solution to their sudden lack of funds.
That’s happening now. All the leftwing fury about “Red States” not expanding Medicaid and so forth is the result of what you described. Even without the handful of bus transfers, it was inevitable that the “migrants” would end up in places with lots of gibs. Red State politicians tend to be greedy cowards, and there is an upside to their greed in this instance.
This is as old as when I was young. In NYC and other major metro areas in what we now term Blue States, Blacks were moving from the rural South up North and collecting welfare immediately. If I recall they were backed up by the Courts when States tried to establish residency requirements before eligibility for such welfare payments.
There are huge headwinds to a formal policy of peaceful separation. Of the biggest are absolutely moronic opposition leaders: https://amgreatness.com/2024/05/29/taking-back-california-part-five-abundant-water/ These guys have been doing a series on how to take back California. At this point, using Anglo-Saxon values, ideas and gentlemanly persuasion to take back California to an American region is no different than trying to do the same with Guatemala. It isn’t going to happen, yet they are going to waste pen, paper, time, money and energy on this stupidity. While they are writing this series, blacks in California’s legislature is accelerating/escalating formal plans to give blacks reparations.… Read more »
“Peaceful separation is the natural state of Americans”
That hasn’t been true since the 1950’s.
Generally when I see someone focused on peaceful separation, I see someone who doesn’t have the psychological makeup to free oneself from his chains.
America is more segregated now than 1950.
By what metric is it more segregated?
I find your claim impossible to believe. In a 90% white country, by sheer chance alone, you would be more likely totally surrounded by white people.
I’m sure you could find some strange statistic that supports your claim if you ignore everything else. I wasn’t around in the 1950s, but from my own lived experiences I’m sure as heck less segregated than I was in 1980.
Look at public schools, which are a great proxy. Tons of reports with lots of data. The public schools are as segregated now as in the 1960’s, despite massive efforts to integrate them. White people move away from diversity. The diversity tries to follow, but housing costs discriminate so the people do have to.
Here’s my observation from growing up in suburban Chicago. As a kid I would go to the high school basketball games and later play, and essentially all of the suburban teams in the Northwest/Western suburbs were completely white in the 70s, with the exception being the older cities like Aurora, Joliet and Elgin, which had poor sections of town. But generally it was suburbs white, half of Chicago black. In the 80’s that started to change, with blacks trickling in here and there. In the 90s and 2000s there were quite a few more blacks on the basketball teams, making… Read more »
Schools are a good example of a “type” of segregation, but that’s because Whites—and others—have been driven to private alternatives such as home schooling and charters. This of course leaves minorities with the “free” or government alternative. My city is a national example of exactly that. We had the *last* school district in the nation under the *longest* court desegregation order—40+ years! It was finally removed/lifted (last I heard) after a successful challenge that there were *no* Whites left in the system to enable the court mandated desegregation. 😉 Housing and living arrangements might be another story. There still seems… Read more »
Look at public schools, which are a great proxy. Tons of reports with lots of data. As predicted, you are offering me a strange statistic that ignores the “enriched” lives that all these children will experience in the workplace, at the store, public parks, and everything else. I would also suspect that the statistics look narrowly at the black/white divide and does not include all the Changs, Pejeets, and Gonzales that white children have to go to school with. I’m sure the rate was near zero in 1950 outside of California or Southern Texas. Even if you are right about… Read more »
I grew up downstate. High school grad early 70’s. Watching the IHSA bball tournaments (a big deal back then) would bear out what you stated. Every now and then a small white hs down state could compete with the Chicagoland schools like Proviso, Marshall. Dolton-Thornridge, et al.
Housing prices are through the roof around here, and so is diversity. At least by local standards. All I can think, your tax dollars at work!
Where I live, a lot of that is rich private schools recruiting blacks to play on their teams, and is not necessarily a trend for the overall population.
Don’t worry about the Pajeet offsprings’ education: they’ll be occupying seats in the best independent schools and paying for it, too. No DIE/AA scholarships needed for this crowd. They just take over, many of them as physician$ in a community. They’re not picking grapes. BTW they’re also happy to run for office, some even seeing themselves as US Senators! At the very least, watch as they run for school board;-) Nervy bastards, aren’t they?
https://news.berkeley.edu/2021/06/21/how-american-racism-is-rooted-in-residential-segregation/
Even the Lefties are making Z’s point.
the funny part is the whites who scream the loudest about racism live in lily white communities far from diversity.
Occasionally, they’ll adopt some diversity. Or maybe a couple people get through the gates and improve the school basketball team. And they’ll pat themselves on the back about how tolerant they are.
Those who champion diversity the loudest are those who can most afford to avoid it.
I believe Zman is correct if confined to white/black communities. The recent Hispanic diversity is more integrated.
I think the failure of multiracialism is very likely for a number of convergent reasons. First is the fading memory of the historical events and the literal death of the generations that created, for the first time ever, social engineering on a global scale. Namely, Mustache Guy’s 1939-1945 racial bloodbath, which created the dominance of racial “reformers” who used WWII as a club to beat race realists without mercy in the postwar era. This led directly to the end of formal colonialism worldwide and formal segregation in the United States. The “Civil Rights” movement could not have taken the form… Read more »
Hitler was right regarding the Sudatenland.
I hope you’re right. Unfortunately there are still too many people who see continued African failure as proof that racism is worse than we thought. It’s so pervasive you can’t even see it because it’s everywhere.
This seems to be your spin on Uncle Jared’s video of a couple of weeks ago.
It seems to be the only way forward is the only way out.
“Because whites will remain the largest population and will increase their self-segregation in response to their shrinking majority and the cultural assault on them from the elites, the racial tyranny must collapse.” Not sure this conclusion invariably follows the premises in today’s missive. Cultural—which is really what it’s all about for the typical White—assault continues and will continue as long as we live in the same country/society as the minorities that drive that cultural decline. Separation entails not just living out of sight of non-Whites, but living in a community that reinforces White culture—and there is a ‘White” culture regardless… Read more »
OT:
The competency crisis rolls on as the Gaza floating pier is broken up by high seas and winds:
https://www.zerohedge.com/geopolitical/gaza-pier-operations-suspended-indefinitely-after-it-breaks-apart-heavy-seas
Sometimes we can only cheer incompetence.
“Incompetence to the rescue!”
Never thought I’d hear that one. God throwing sand in the gears proves that God is on our side. God, as they say, is one of /our/ guys.
I agree with Z. Peaceful separation it must and will be, but with the proviso that the separation will take the form of the ethnostate or ethnostates.
While I agree it would be near impossible to completely eliminate “diversity” getting rid of the vast majority of it would not be difficult. Blacks are here to stay, there can be no getting rid of them. But most of the Central and South Americans would be fairly easy to get rid of. They walked here. They have foreign identities and citizenship. Walking back to Mexico or Venezuela just isn’t that difficult. The idea that these people will not leave if we got serious about their being here is a preposterous lie told by the ruling elite in order to… Read more »
If Alvin Bragg, as a local county prosecutor, can enforce federal election laws, why can’t a local Texas prosecutor enforce federal immigration laws? Of course, federal judges will play it both ways and not allow this. But I can think of a lot of ways where local prosecutors can make examples of illegals, for example by charging them with local crimes and detaining them for years without trial. Perhaps enough to scare them into not coming, or even better going home.
The problem is both parties support the status quo. There needs to be a change in attitude among the elite. The population mostly supports shutting down the border and repatriating a lot of these criminal invaders. I think this is largely because the elite get the benefits and we pay the costs.
The diversity will demand to control weapons of mass destruction and delivery means. Do whites accede or reserve exclusive rights? What recourse for whites if foreigners are invited to occupy diverse territory with WMD? Control waterways, farmland and other resources? Nuke plants?
Peaceful separation could only work out well if the parties are, and they remain, reasonable. The diversity is not and it couldn’t sustain reasonableness. Not as its leadership envies the ascending white civilization.
Peaceful resolution isn’t a realistic prospect.
This encapsulates the demographics involved.
…The House passed the budget just after 2 a.m. Wednesday morning. Despite having the majority, Democrats still had to solve some infighting before they could pass the bill. While the governor and state Democrats applaud themselves for passage, state Republicans call the budget a partisan nightmare for taxpayers…
Is that not par for the course in IL politics – Chicagoland against downstate? (This also seems to be analogous to the Beltway vs flyover country).
Yea it’s a false hope to keep everyone docile until they are extinguished…
The Salvador Option: bring the traitor judiciary to heel and then place every single white with a facial tattoo in protective custody.
I don’t know, Z-man; I’ve seen the future on the big screen all my life and the future is diverse: Star-trek, Fire-fly, Star-wars, Masters of the Galaxy…Oh wait, there was one with only white folks, but HAL tried to kill Dave in that one.
Oh, and, one other where Bruce Dern is sent adrift with a green house of plants and a wee robot.
So, there it is: Either embrace diversity as our strength, or we’ll never make it past Jupiter.
My glimpse of the present/future was watching the homo white male CEO of Apple supplicate to the disdainful fat negro “mother nature.” Taking in this zeitgeist, I conclude that we are going on to the bitter end, whatever that entails. I’d rather buy a Korean phone.
Anyway, are the “elites” acting on their own initiative or is someone else dictating their actions to them?
James Madison had the solution to this problem in 1787. He discussed “the mischiefs of faction” quite eloquently in Federalist #10. His solution to the problem was to create a federal system of diverse states and a central government of strictly limited and enumerated powers. Unfortunately the federal government that he created became the monster that ate the Constitution. Under Lincoln, the federal government, in search of a reason to kill Southern white people and destroy their political power, decided that Negro slavery gave it the moral justification to do so. The federal government has used forced racial “diversity” and… Read more »
Iirc, the frontier was officially declared closed in one of the late 19th century censuses. It was, of course, closing long before the authorities said so, which could’ve been a cause of the Civil War. Without the pressure-release valve, somebody had to take over. Post-reconstruction, Yankeedom worked OK. Post-WWII, the frontier mentality made a fake and gay comeback, thanks to the automobile and radio/TV. Probably inflation, too. Not a true frontier thing, because travel and information kept people tethered. It’s probably not a coincidence that westerns were so popular then, or that rugged individualism is so popular with people of… Read more »