My pet theory about why societies decline is that their ruling classes lose the will or incentive to enforce the rules they created to govern themselves. It’s a take on the broken windows theory of law enforcement. Once you start letting the little violations go, the next level of crimes are then permitted. The rot creeps higher and higher until no rules are enforced or seen as a deterrent. Without Marius, there can be no Caesar.
It’s not linear or inevitable. New York City reformed itself. Giuliani sorted out the police force and prosecutors office, cracked down on petty crime and began a program of ethnic cleansing. The people running the city, the wealthy financial class, no longer saw any benefit to letting the lunatics run the place so they brought in a new man to address the problems. They had an incentive to do so, which was the need for safe, livable real estate for their servants.
The Romans, in contrast, never had an incentive to reform their system and return to a republic. The Senatorial class saw their interests in centralized authority and therefore went along with the drift toward empire. Given the choice between one of their own having dictatorial power and sharing power with the lower classes, they chose the former. That meant ignoring all of those rules and customs of the republic. When that was not practical, they invented clever ways around those rules and customs.
In modern America, you see much of the same at the top. The Obama administration looks at the law as a puzzle to solve so they can get around the limits. Congress routinely looks the other way as their own rules are broken. Boehner and McConnell see a benefit in letting the executive run wild. It spares them the risk of doing their job and lets them collect massive amounts of cash. There are a lot of rich men in Congress who came to Washington penniless.
The problem with rot at the top in a modern society is it tends to spread to the more mundane parts of the empire. This story from the backwaters of the America South is a good example.
The latest example of cellphone video vindicating someone from false charges is a doozy. It comes from Washington Parish, La., and WWL TV.
One of the worst days of Douglas Dendinger’s life began with him handing an envelope to a police officer.
In order to help out his family and earn a quick $50, Dendinger agreed to act as a process server, giving a brutality lawsuit filed by his nephew to Chad Cassard as the former Bogalusa police officer exited the Washington Parish Courthouse.
The handoff went smoothly, but Dendinger said the reaction from Cassard, and a group of officers and attorneys clustered around him, turned his life upside down.
“It was like sticking a stick in a bee’s nest.” Dendinger, 47, recalled. “They started cursing me. They threw the summons at me. Right at my face, but it fell short. Vulgarities. I just didn’t know what to think. I was a little shocked.”
Not knowing what to make of the blow-up, a puzzled Dendinger drove home. That’s where things went from bad to worse.
“Within about 20 minutes, there were these bright lights shining through my windows. It was like, ‘Oh my God.’ I mean I knew immediately, a police car.”
“And that’s when the nightmare started,” he said. “I was arrested.”
He was not only arrested, he was also charged with two felonies and a misdemeanor. A prior drug charge on his record meant he was potentially looking at decades in prison. Seven witnesses backed up the police account that Dendinger had assaulted Cassard.
But Dendinger had asked his wife and nephew to record him serving the papers. It was a last minute decision, but one that may have saved him his freedom.
From what can be seen on the clips, Dendinger never touches Cassard, who calmly takes the envelope and walks back into the courthouse, handing [prosecutor Leigh Anne] Wall the envelope.
“He’d still be in a world of trouble if he didn’t have that film,” said David Cressy, a friend of Dendinger who once served as a prosecutor under [former St. Tammany District Attorney Walter] Reed. “It was him against all of them. They took advantage of that and said all sorts of fictitious things happened. And it didn’t happen. It would still be going like that had they not had the film.”
Dendinger spent nearly a year waiting for trial, racking up attorney’s fees. As a disabled Army veteran on a fixed income, Dendinger said the case stretched him financially, but in his eyes, he was fighting for his life.
After nearly a year passed, his attorneys forced Reed to recuse his office. The case was referred to the Louisiana Attorney General’s Office, which promptly dropped the charges.
Rafael Goyeneche, president of the Metropolitan Crime Commission and himself a former prosecutor, studied the videos. He did not hesitate in his assessment.
“I didn’t see a battery, certainly a battery committed that would warrant criminal charges,” Goyeneche said. “And more importantly, the attorney general’s office didn’t see a battery.”
That’s all well and good. And Dendinger has since filed a federal civil rights lawsuit. I hope he collects.
But here’s my question: Why aren’t the seven witnesses to Dendinger’s nonexistent assault on Cassard already facing felony charges? Why are all but one of the cops who filed false reports still wearing badges and collecting paychecks? Why aren’t the attorneys who filed false reports facing disbarment? Dendinger’s prosecutors both filed false reports, then prosecuted Dendinger based on the reports they knew were false. They should be looking for new careers — after they get out of jail.
If a group of regular citizens had pulled this on someone, they’d all likely be facing criminal conspiracy charges on top of the perjury and other charges. So why aren’t these cops and prosecutors?
I could be wrong, but my guess is that they’ll all be let off due to “professional courtesy” or some sort of exercise of prosecutorial discretion. And so the people who ought to be held to a higher standard than the rest of us will once again be held to a lower one.
This is something we see everywhere at the top. Jon Corzine stole billions from his clients, breaking many laws in the process. He is given a pass because he is a one of the beautiful people. The CIA gets caught spying on members of Congress and nothing happens. No one goes to jail for what used to be considered the highest crime imaginable in a republic.
This rot at the top filters down so that the local prosecutor gets away with what should result in prison time. Everyone in the ghetto, for example, knows better than to talk to a cop because cops get to lie and break the law. No good comes from dealing with the cops so no one talks to the cops. The orderly society is thrown into reverse.
Herbert Stein’s Law comes to mind, but probably does not apply. There’s no reason to think the decay of social order in America must stop or that people in charge will reform themselves. There are plenty of examples where societies went through periods of reform and renewal, but there are examples of ones that simply collapsed. The stories above suggest the rot is deep and far advanced. Reform may simply be impossible.
Two of my kids were assaulted and one held against her will by a county cop’s son. The judicial nightmare afterwards went on for a year. Three judges recused themselves after admitting they were friends of the family and I finally persuaded the state to send in a state prosecutor due to the county prosecutor collaborating with the accused and lying on his behalf. The transfer of the case resulted in missing key evidence (the gun and phone records just disappeared) as well as an altered police report, a cop being retired, and one of the investigating officers on our side killed in a freak accident after his head somehow hit a sign on a sign post they say. I had social services at my home, threats of charges from the prosecutor’s office… the amount of corruption was astonishing and scary. It should have been a simple case because we had witnesses, phone records, the gun, and two recordings precisely describing what happened. We ended up losing. GOOD JOB PROTECTING YOUR OWN YOU CORRUPT BASTARDS!
John F’in Kerry was and is broke. His personal currency as a man is worthless. His recent TV thing was right out of The Twilight Zone meets 1984.
Double speak Esperanto mixed with platitudes, parables and new-think failed dogma. He makes used car dealers look sincere.
I don’t think many of our elected representatives (and I mean all houses, state and national) were “penniless” when they got to their positions, except in a relative sort of way. They damn sure don’t leave with less than they had when they started.
John Forbes Kerry was broke when he arrived in Washington. He literally had no money, not even enough to rent a place initially. He left the Senate as the richest man in both houses. Granted, he bagged two rich widows in his time in DC, but he also used insider trading rules to amass a fortune.
Ditto, Tripletap, ditto.
I knew we were in trouble when one of the first things the Obama administration announced upon taking office, they would no longer enforce the DOMA. Failure to enforce our immigration laws followed closely and the continuing slide of lawlessness continues to this day. It’s not enough for this bozo to have affirmatively actioned his way to the top of our government, but he relishes in flaunting the office and pushing limits beyond boundaries imagined by our founders. Obama voters, I really hate you.
Senatorial class saw their interests in centralized authority and therefore went along with the drift toward empire. Given the choice between one of their own having dictatorial power and sharing power with the lower classes, they chose the former.
Brutus and Cassius beg to differ.
Brutus and Cassius beg to differ.
How’d that work out?
If the ruling elite of Rome really wanted to restore the republic, they would have done it.
We are learning to do a great many clever things. The next great task will be to learn not to do them-
Burke
A fitting quote from Le Cygne Gris:
“We are stuck on the modernist myth of America, a nation of laws. Unfortunately, laws without morality are merely hoops to jump through, and no number of codified regulations can save a nation that is morally corrupt for, fundamentally, laws must be interpreted and enforced by men.
Thus, we are clinging to the false god of rule of law.
The truth is that we have always been ruled by men all along. Now that men are thoroughly corrupt, we see what a charade rule of law really is.”
The other day a guy told me that in his view you couldn’t trust the police. Normally I’d let such comment pass but he also told me he had been cop, so he had seen the untrustworthiness from the inside.
I tend to regard Robert Peel as a sort of hero in that he wanted a police force that was just as much subject to law as everyone else was but were people empowered to make lawful arrests and therefore help bring order to society. Over the past near-200 years the reputation of the police force has fallen and increasingly many people believe that as the police cannot and will not protect ordinary citizens then it is best for the law-abiding population to make whatever lawful arrangements they can to protect themselves.
My thankfully limited experience of crime involved me once calling the police about a minor crime committed against my property and all I got was a number for the purposes of insurance to show the cops had received my call. I am not alone in thinking “why bother calling?”
It reminds me of the joke about the man who calls the cops to say a burglar is in his garden shed and he is told that they are all too busy to respond and they’d be along in a couple of hours. So, a few minutes later he called the cops and said not to worry as he had killed the burglar.
Within a minute cop cars with lights flashing swooped on his house, a police helicopter appeared overhead and a dozen police officers rushed to the shed. No one was there, and no body.
“I thought you said you killed a man,” said one exasperated cop.
“And I thought you said you were too busy,” said the man.
Funny-true maybe, but I bet he was charged with wasting police time after the laughter died down.
In Suffolk County New York, the police no longer respond to break ins. They don’t take finger prints or collect evidence. Unless someone is harmed or government property is involved, they consider it an insurance issue. No police department in America looks for stolen cars. For the most part, the only reason you involve the police in these matters is the insurance company requires a police report.