Alone in the Universe

The Drake equation is the estimate for the number of technological civilizations that may exist in our galaxy. Astronomer Frank Drake came up with a list of specific factors that are essential to the development of intelligent life. The Wiki entry is pretty good and worth reading if you like. If you want something a little more casual, space.com has a nice article on it. The Drake equation is pretty much all the alien hunters have at the moment, given that we have zero evidence of life beyond this planet.

The reason for that is a mystery. In fact, it has a cool name as well. It is called the Fermi Paradox. There are billions of stars in the galaxy. The math says there should be millions with planets similar to earth and capable of life. That’s the paradox. The math says there should be lots of earth like planets teaming with life that has evolved for a lot longer than life on earth. Yet, as far as we know, we are alone in the universe, but we keep looking.

This story the other day is interesting.

Astronomers using the TRAPPIST telescope at ESO’s La Silla Observatory have discovered three planets orbiting an ultracool dwarf star just 40 light-years from Earth. These worlds have sizes and temperatures similar to those of Venus and Earth and are the best targets found so far for the search for life outside the Solar System. They are the first planets ever discovered around such a tiny and dim star. The new results will be published in the journal Nature on 2 May 2016.

A team of astronomers led by Michaël Gillon, of the Institut d’Astrophysique et Géophysique at the University of Liège in Belgium, have used the Belgian TRAPPIST telescope [1] to observe the star 2MASS J23062928-0502285, now also known as TRAPPIST-1. They found that this dim and cool star faded slightly at regular intervals, indicating that several objects were passing between the star and the Earth [2]. Detailed analysis showed that three planets with similar sizes to the Earth were present.

A light year is roughly 5.9 trillion miles so these planets are roughly 240 trillion miles from earth. To put that into some perspective, let’s pretend there is intelligent life on one of these planets. They decide to let us know they are there by using a light signal of some sort to send Morse Code. By the time we received the signal and decoded it, most of the people who sent it would be dead. By the time they got our reply, they would all be dead and most the people on our end would be dead.

Traveling to these planets would be impossible for humans. The fastest space vehicle we have is the upcoming Solar Orbiter that NASA plans to launch in 2018. It will travel at 450,000 miles an hour. If that were configured to haul humans, it would arrive in the vicinity of these planets around the year 62,899. Our astronauts would not even be dust at that point.  Even assuming we can build a vehicle to reach something close to light speed, we’re still looking at having geezers showing up to the alien planet.

The other side of this is that the alien planet could have a species that has solved these technological problems. They have the ability to reach speeds in excess of light and the ability to survive in deep space for extended periods. The challenges of interstellar space travel are many orders of magnitude more difficult than anything we understand. That would most likely mean they are vastly more advanced than humans in every way.

The size of the technological gap between us and them would be something similar to modern humans and australopithecines. Our technology is amazing to us, just as sharp sticks were amazing to Australopithecus. To the people able to conquer interstellar travel, our technology would be the equivalent to the sharp stick. They will do things we cannot imagine doing, much less understand doing.

One of those things, most likely, will be the ability to conceal themselves from us. Interstellar travel will require manipulation of matter on a grand scale. Long before they figured out the Warp drive, they will have figured out how to hide from our level of technology. We’re getting pretty good at hiding from radar and the visible spectrum. Our alien visitors will certainly have expanded this ability into most of the electromagnetic spectrum.

Of course, the ability to control matter at the scales required of Warp drives means they would have the ability to control living matter as well. We like to think we’re complicated and by the standards of earth, we are complicated. By alien standards, we are single cell creatures in a water bath. They would be able to manipulate us just as easily as we control ants and roaches. For all we know, earth is just a really big terrarium anyway.

Then you have the evolutionary issues. Humans today are nothing like the humans of 200,000 years ago. Imagine what we will be like in 200,000 years. Intelligent life in a million years could very well be microscopic organisms living in silica. What if Hawking is more right than he knows and the future of intelligent life is at the smallest of small scale? That means our alien visitors could very well be a dust storm or the single facet of a snowflake.

The point here is that we are alone in the universe, as far we know and as far as we will ever know. By the time we can know otherwise, we will not be us. By the time the aliens can show up and set us straight, they will be so far advanced compared to us we will not be able to detect them anyway. For all any of us can know, we’re just a science experiment for some distant race of life. Earth is a terrarium sitting on a kid’s desk. Regardless, we are alone in this universe and we always will be alone.

39 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Drake
Drake
8 years ago

Perhaps other intelligent species aren’t broadcasting their presence for the same reason that deer and rabbits don’t roar or howl at the moon – there are predators.

John the River
Reply to  Drake
8 years ago

I think that is called the ‘Hunters of the Dawn’ theory. As civilizations rise and begin to emit RF noise, xenophobic alien races immediately dispatch a planet killer; a comet, a black hole, or democrats…

Fuel Filter
Fuel Filter
8 years ago

Yes, we are functionally alone so all this back and forth is an exercise in futility. The real issue for me is our space program (and the lack of it). We would have already have had an American presence on Mars if it weren’t for all the social programs (“Great Society”, 46 million on food stamps),  Wilson and  FDR setting the stage for Statism (not to mention Communism), trillions spent on wars lost by Democrats beginning with Korea (actually Yalta. Thanks for that Harry Hopkins and FDR) and all the other pernicious bullshit the statist Left has foisted upon us.… Read more »

james wilson
james wilson
Reply to  Fuel Filter
8 years ago

The space program WAS a socialist program. By the time it hit middle age it was already moribund, and all it did well was to prevent the entry of private enterprise into space. Then old age sank it to lower lows until The One hisself put it out of it’s misery. Curious how we wind up cheering for the wrong side because the enemy has crossed the fence and confused the boundaries.

Terry Baker
Reply to  james wilson
8 years ago

james wilson – I think you’re right. War socialism was the space program’s foundation when it was a race with a deadly rival. Absent that, it has slowly decayed. Collective salvation is an illusion.

TWS
TWS
8 years ago

Some believe the reason the cosmos are so quiet is because the noisy chick gets eaten. Any cosmic civilization will eventually become a danger to others around it. Thus any artificial radio communications are either a potential danger or a trap to lure somebody into revealing their position.

Once you know the position of the ‘enemy’ you can simply destroy their planet with a big enough rock. We know how and we’ve barely left our planet.

neal
neal
Member
Reply to  TWS
8 years ago

Well, if most information just is perceived as background radiation, and stray neutrinos, then perhaps radiological mutation is just getting shit together. I do not know why organic life would not be a small fish in a really big sea.

RobM
RobM
Member
8 years ago

Another great read. I find the desperate search for other life and other planets most passionate in folks that are anti-religion and/or Christianity. They are agnostic or athiest, seems, but are determined to find other life, as that validates their view of humans on Earth, the special-ness of Earth, and humans. Much like internationalists within the US are bound and determined to make sure no one thinks the US is a very special country as formed , and must be shown to be not so special and even unfairly prosperous. I could be wrong, but that’s how I see it.… Read more »

Casius Lucius
Casius Lucius
8 years ago

How have humans changed from 200k years ago? Physically they are pretty much the same (lighter bones and teeth now) but something catalyzed our cognitive abilities about 10k years ago. That is the key to the big riddle, I think.

Strelnikov
Member
Reply to  Casius Lucius
8 years ago

Monolith.

Montefrío
Member
8 years ago

I believe the “universe” is holographic and recommend the late David Bohm’s “Wholeness and the Implicate Order” to anyone interested in the assumption. I’m also a nearly unconditionally convinced Zen practitioner and for anyone with an interest in how that relates to the holographic universe, reading “The Zen Teachings of Huang Po” is sufficient.

Member
8 years ago

I’ve come to the conclusion the universe may be the nursery for many, many sentient beings, but that whoever made the universe didn’t really want them to meet in time and space.

Yellow Umbrella
Yellow Umbrella
8 years ago

Even assuming we can build a vehicle to reach something close to light speed, we’re still looking at having geezers showing up to the alien planet…..

Not so as the closer you travel to the speed of light the more time slows down so the astronauts on the spaceship would still be young but their twin siblings on Earth would be geezers.

I grew up in the 1970s and remember predictions that we would have a manned base on Mars by 2014….

James LePore
8 years ago

Not only are we alone in the universe, but if we continue searching the cosmos looking for and hoping to find “alien beings” or “life” like ours, we will go mad. (http://jlepore.fineartstudioonline.com/blog/95417/that-way-lies-madness).

The real journey is inward, into the depths of our own individual minds, hearts and souls.

Reply to  James LePore
8 years ago

random observer 2011 New commenter here. Thanks for the link to your site- I’m just starting to work through your recent stuff. Some I haven’t really gotten but “Dancing with the Devil” and “The Last White Male” are quite provocative. Good use of the ‘really short’ story form. Spare, but generates strong mental imagery. On the subject of the moment, I did read “That way lies madness”. Would you care to elaborate on your point? I didn’t quite click with it but this is a subject of interest for me. The immensity of the universe is one of those things… Read more »

James LePore
Reply to  random_observer_2011
8 years ago

I first started thinking about the futility of looking for an answer in the cosmos when I saw 2001, A Space Odyssey, circa 1972. My point in That Way Lies Madness was the same as ( in my view) was made in the movie and the novel: you will go mad if you search for meaning as a separate thing unto itself, God, if you will, as a big powerful thing at the edge of the universe. I am still groping at this, but my heart tells me the search for God in an interior one. The very idea of… Read more »

John Hinds
Reply to  James LePore
8 years ago

The search for meaning, for G_d, IS the purpose. Its not about arriving somewhere, its about the journey – to nowhere. If you do ‘arrive’ you likely find you are back at your beginning yet you know the place for the first time. Sentient life – to me this is self evident – is a mechanism whereby the cosmos has a sense of self experience. Yet, G_d does not exist. Impossible. He is eternal. Only things have existence. Its all an illusion, people. “Born, I cannot die. Dead, I cannot be born.” We little ants are the means to overcome… Read more »

Reply to  James LePore
8 years ago

Thanks for this reply. I’m working my way through our host’s archives. Not disappointed yet. Depressed, occasionally. Your elaboration was clarifying for me. I would tend to agree, though I’m not sure the inner exploration will necessarily be more fruitful in the end, nor less maddening as we find meaning ungraspable therein as well. Either way, you gave me a further point worth thinking about- I have never really thought of the desire for space exploration as, or at least not entirely as, the quest for meaning or the search for God. For wealth and power, for species long-term survival,… Read more »

Sam J.
Sam J.
8 years ago

Scientist are now saying 50% of the mass of the universe is dark. Maybe they’re hiding. From what is the question.

Strelnikov
Member
8 years ago

We’ll find out when NAFAL interstellar travel is invented. Any day now. Also the ansible. Just around the corner.

Cambias
8 years ago

Earth is such a tiny, miniscule part of the Universe. How can anyone not want to know about the rest of everything?

james wilson
james wilson
8 years ago

If Einstein rules, the speed of light is an interstellar stop sign. But if he was only as right as, say, Issac Newton, we may be a hot venue on the interstellar tourist map right now. Surely this place is more interesting than a zoo. Until the day comes that somebody explains spooky action at a distance, nobody even knows what’s impossible.

UKer
UKer
8 years ago

Aliens are flying above our head as we speak. Unfortunately, due to a galactic design flaw, their spacecraft look like clouds.

Of course, they don’t want to let us know they exist in any event because, you know, that immigrant thing.

IronBrigade
IronBrigade
Reply to  UKer
8 years ago

Naw! The aliens are a most helpful bunch. I caught a glimpse of a title of one of their book-length essays.

It was called “To Serve Mankind”.

Okay, okay! Credit to Rod Serling and his crew.

Dan Kurt
Dan Kurt
Member
Reply to  IronBrigade
8 years ago

Before Rod Serling’s tv show was Damon Knight’s short story here:
http://archive[DOT]org/stream/galaxymagazine-1950-11/Galaxy_1950_11#page/n91/mode/2up

alzaebo
alzaebo
8 years ago

“around the year 62,899. Our astronauts would not even be dust at that point.” That brought home for me the genius of nature. Nested, encoded information endures, even in transitory vessels such as ourselves. Big fan of Steven Baxter SF scenarios of the sturdy primate form extending 10, 30, 500 million years in the future.   I remember an old story wherein the alien progenitors had stored star tech in beetle DNA, beetles haven’t changed in an absurdly long time. Also agree with Bruce Sterling that the best way to colonize space would be rock-hopping the rubble of the Oort… Read more »

alzaebo
alzaebo
Reply to  alzaebo
8 years ago

Plus, I dream of a time when all that remains of Earth’s lost history is found in an ancient derelict: copies of two hero stories, “Conan the Barbarian” and “Conan the Destroyer”.

Guest
Guest
8 years ago

>> Then you have the evolutionary issues. Humans today are nothing like the humans of 200,000 years ago. Imagine what we will be like in 200,000 years. All evidence indicates that humans are finished evolving, at least in any sort of meaningfully positive way. Existing technology has all but conquered the environment, eliminating they type of competitive adaptation pressures which caused the species to evolve. Population growth is now dysgenic rather than eugenic and average IQs are falling. Most humans of the future are quite likely to be dumber than most humans of the present, hence Idiocracy. Competitive adaptation of… Read more »

antipater_1
antipater_1
Reply to  Guest
8 years ago

“Population growth is now dysgenic rather than eugenic and average IQs are falling”
Dysgenic versus eugenic population growth may be the only thing that can keep humans alive as a species for a million years. On the other hand, Hinduism claims humans have existed for millions of years already.

IronBrigade
IronBrigade
Reply to  Guest
8 years ago

Anyone who believes that “All evidence indicates that humans are finished evolving, at least in any sort of meaningfully positive way” just hasn’t visited a Walmart lately…..

Oh….wait….you said “evolved” and “positive”…..

Never mind!

Strelnikov
Member
Reply to  IronBrigade
8 years ago

We are Devo.

Tim
Tim
Member
8 years ago

Well, I always thought “it’s probably aliens that did this” but figured that was jut me. Now, I know I’m not alone in thinking this. Thanks, Zman, I feel much better now. Tim

jdallen
jdallen
8 years ago

“any sufficiently developed technology is indistinguishable from magic”

Casius Lucius
Casius Lucius
Reply to  jdallen
8 years ago

At least give Arthur credit for that quote 🙂

vanderleun
Member
Reply to  Casius Lucius
8 years ago

Any sufficiently developed reader knows the credit for that quote.

John the River
Reply to  vanderleun
8 years ago

Arthur C. Clark, the author of the short story that was developed into 2001 A Space Odyssey.
For the benefit of the legion of young high school students like my nephew who never read science fiction or think about things that they don’t like to thing about.

IronBrigade
IronBrigade
Reply to  jdallen
8 years ago

Ol’ Art was partially right. To be more accurate, it should read, “any developed technology is magic.”

The first atlatl which killed a deer from 30 yards was “magic” to a Neanderthal. So does one consider a notched stick to be “sufficiently developed technology?”